Islam Makhachev has quickly become one of the most dominant forces in the UFC, and after his recent victories, many are beginning to ask: Is he now the greatest lightweight fighter in MMA history?
The question is a natural one, considering Makhachev’s continued rise in the lightweight division. With his technical skills, near-perfect fight IQ, and a growing list of impressive victories, he has already established himself as a future legend of the sport. But does he have what it takes to surpass the likes of Khabib Nurmagomedov, Conor McGregor, and other lightweight greats? Here’s a closer look at Makhachev’s accomplishments, his style, and what makes him a legitimate contender for the title of “greatest lightweight ever.”
Makhachev’s Impressive Rise to the Top
Islam Makhachev’s rise to UFC superstardom has been both methodical and spectacular. Since his UFC debut in 2015, Makhachev has steadily racked up victories, building a reputation for his relentless grappling, dominant control, and striking improvements. His journey to the lightweight title was not a fluke, but rather the result of years of dedicated work and strategic planning.
Makhachev’s most significant moment came in October 2022 when he defeated Charles Oliveira at UFC 280 for the UFC Lightweight Championship. The victory was a crowning achievement for the Russian fighter, who not only claimed the title but also showcased his incredible grappling skills by outwrestling one of the most dangerous submission artists in MMA history. This win immediately solidified his status as one of the best lightweight fighters in the world.
A Dominant Style Built on Khabib’s Legacy
Islam Makhachev’s fighting style has often been compared to that of his mentor, Khabib Nurmagomedov, the undefeated former UFC lightweight champion. Both fighters are known for their exceptional wrestling and ground control, using relentless pressure to break down their opponents. However, Makhachev has also demonstrated a more refined and diverse striking game, which sets him apart from Khabib’s early style.
Where Khabib was famous for his ability to drag opponents into deep waters and dominate them with suffocating pressure, Makhachev has proven to be more versatile. His stand-up striking has evolved to a point where he can mix in powerful kicks and punches, often setting up his takedowns with precise timing. Makhachev has shown that he can dominate both on the ground and on the feet, making him a more well-rounded fighter than many of his predecessors.
Key Victories and Challenges
Islam Makhachev’s record is a testament to his skill and consistency. In addition to his victory over Oliveira, he has defeated several top contenders, including Dan Hooker, Bobby Green, and most recently, Alexander Volkanovski. Each of these wins has reinforced Makhachev’s claim to the throne as the lightweight king, but they also show that Makhachev is capable of defeating elite talent across a variety of fighting styles.
However, the competition in the lightweight division remains fierce. Fighters like Charles Oliveira, Justin Gaethje, and Dustin Poirier continue to be formidable opponents, and Makhachev will need to continue proving himself in dominant fashion to truly cement his legacy as the greatest lightweight ever.
The Legacy of Khabib and the Influence on Makhachev
It’s impossible to talk about Islam Makhachev without mentioning his relationship with Khabib Nurmagomedov. The two have been close friends and training partners for years, and Khabib’s undefeated legacy has undoubtedly influenced Makhachev’s approach to the sport. Khabib’s career, marked by his perfect 29-0 record, made him an iconic figure in MMA, and Makhachev has often been seen as the fighter most capable of carrying on Khabib’s legacy in the lightweight division.
Khabib’s influence on Makhachev is apparent not only in their shared fighting style but also in their similar mindset towards competition. Both fighters have demonstrated an unwavering focus on domination, rather than seeking flashiness or accolades. For Makhachev, the pursuit of greatness seems driven by a desire to follow in Khabib’s footsteps—except with the added challenge of carving out his own unique path as the new face of the lightweight division.
Comparing Makhachev to Other Lightweight Greats
When discussing whether Islam Makhachev is the greatest lightweight ever, it’s important to consider the legends that have come before him. Fighters like Conor McGregor, BJ Penn, and Eddie Alvarez all held significant achievements in the lightweight division, and of course, Khabib Nurmagomedov remains the gold standard in many fans’ eyes. Khabib’s undefeated record and dominance throughout his career make him a hard act to follow, but Makhachev’s ability to consistently defeat top-tier opponents, particularly in his last few fights, makes him a serious contender.
While McGregor’s time as lightweight champion was marked by groundbreaking success, particularly with his two-division championship, his career has been plagued with inconsistency since his prime years. On the other hand, Khabib’s legacy is untarnished, and his success over top competition like Gaethje and Poirier cements his place in history. Makhachev has yet to face some of these same opponents, so his legacy is still a work in progress.
What Does Makhachev Need to Do to Be the Greatest?
To solidify his claim as the greatest lightweight ever, Makhachev needs to continue dominating the division with precision and consistency. A few more victories over top contenders and a successful title defense against fighters like Oliveira, Gaethje, or Charles Oliveira will go a long way in enhancing his legacy. Additionally, if he can remain undefeated for a long period and extend his reign as lightweight champion, the argument for his place at the top will become even stronger.
The lightweight division has always been one of the most competitive in MMA, and Makhachev will need to prove that he can consistently overcome the best in the division over time. It’s not enough to just win the title; Makhachev must defend it against all comers and leave no doubt about his supremacy.
Conclusion: Is Islam Makhachev The Greatest Lightweight Ever Now?
Islam Makhachev has firmly positioned himself as one of the top fighters in the lightweight division and has a very strong case for being one of the greatest ever. His undefeated streak, dominant performances, and well-rounded fighting style make him a force to be reckoned with. However, surpassing legends like Khabib Nurmagomedov and Conor McGregor will take more than just one or two impressive victories. For now, Makhachev is well on his way, but time and continued dominance will ultimately decide if he truly deserves the title of the greatest lightweight of all time.
