OPINION: This article may contain commentary which reflects the author’s opinion.
The casting of Superman has always been a pivotal decision in the DC Universe, especially for those who carry the weight of the iconic red cape. Zack Snyder’s take on the Man of Steel in the 2013 film Man of Steel was a departure from traditional portrayals, focusing on a darker, more introspective version of the hero. Yet, one element remained unchanged — his choice of Superman. In this case, Henry Cavill stood tall as the only actor who could embody Snyder’s vision of the Kryptonian hero.
The decision to cast Cavill wasn’t one that came easily, nor was it without its controversy. There was another name in the mix: Joe Manganiello. Known for his charismatic role as Alcide Herveaux in True Blood and his intimidating turn as Deathstroke in Zack Snyder’s Justice League, Manganiello was initially considered by Snyder for the role of Superman. In fact, the actor was the director’s second choice.
Snyder spoke openly about his decision in interviews, acknowledging Manganiello’s obvious appeal. His physicality and star power were undeniable, and many fans saw him as an interesting choice to play the legendary hero. However, there was one quality Manganiello’s portrayal of Superman would not have conveyed: innocence. In a conversation with MTV News, Snyder reflected on this delicate balance, explaining that Superman needed “the teeniest bit of innocence.” He emphasized that this trait, though subtle, was essential to capturing the essence of the character: “I mean, he grew up in Kansas, that’s just true, so you need a little of that innocence.”
This was where Cavill stood apart. Despite his muscular physique and undeniable strength, Cavill possessed a unique blend of vulnerability and nobility that Snyder believed was crucial for Superman. The director sought an actor who could portray the character’s inner struggle: a god-like being trying to reconcile his alien heritage with his human upbringing. Cavill’s ability to balance these complexities made him the perfect fit for Snyder’s vision.
Joe Manganiello Missed Out: Zack Snyder’s Justification for Choosing Henry Cavill
While Manganiello’s Superman journey never came to fruition, his near-casting remains an intriguing “what if?” in the history of superhero cinema. In a candid interview on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Manganiello shared details about his audition process, revealing just how close he came to donning the iconic suit. The actor met with key figures involved in the project, including producers and Snyder himself, discussing the direction of the character and how he could contribute to the larger DCEU.
But things took an unexpected turn when Manganiello’s commitments to True Blood proved to be an obstacle. The actor revealed that after a thorough meeting with Snyder, the production team reached out to the True Blood costume shop to get Manganiello’s measurements for the Superman suit. Unfortunately, this logistical hiccup led to the project stalling, and the role ultimately went to Cavill.
Despite this setback, Manganiello’s career continued to thrive. He credited True Blood for launching his career into the superhero realm, which eventually led to his portrayal of Deathstroke in Zack Snyder’s Justice League. Manganiello has since embraced this alternate path, finding satisfaction in his work within the DCEU, even if it wasn’t as Superman.
The Road Not Taken: Joe Manganiello’s Superman Saga Explored
Manganiello’s near casting as Superman has become a fascinating layer to the broader narrative of the DCEU’s evolution. His journey reflects the complex decisions that go into casting such an iconic role, and how the paths actors take are often shaped by timing, circumstance, and the director’s specific vision.
In the end, Snyder’s decision to cast Henry Cavill proved to be a defining moment for the character of Superman. While Joe Manganiello may have been an excellent choice, Snyder’s vision of a more somber, nuanced Superman required someone who could navigate the hero’s internal struggles — qualities that Cavill embodied effortlessly. With Cavill’s Superman, Snyder crafted a hero who wasn’t just a symbol of strength but also of hope and redemption, a reflection of the director’s bold reimagining of the character.
As fans continue to debate and revisit the legacy of Man of Steel, one thing is clear: Henry Cavill’s portrayal of Superman will remain a defining moment in the DCEU, made possible by Snyder’s unwavering belief that he was the only one who could bring the character to life in the way the director envisioned.
