In a compelling episode of their podcast Call It What It Is, Grey’s Anatomy stars Camilla Luddington and Jessica Capshaw addressed the shocking revelations surrounding writer Elizabeth Finch’s fake cancer diagnosis. The discussion follows the release of the Peacock documentary Anatomy of Lies, which explores Finch’s extensive deception during her time on the show.

Unpacking the Deception

The October 28 episode began with Jessica sharing her childhood experiences with lying, highlighting how a significant incident left her feeling immense shame. She pondered the psychology behind deceitful behavior, especially in those who fabricate serious illnesses.

Jessica reflected, “I’m guessing that people who lie about their identities… do not feel remorse or shame about lying,” emphasizing the unsettling mental health aspects involved.

The Fallout of Finch’s Lies

The documentary reveals that Finch claimed to be battling a rare bone cancer beginning in 2012, only confessing to the deceit a decade later in 2022. This revelation profoundly affected her colleagues and loved ones.

Camilla expressed her shock, stating, “You start realizing things are not matching up, and you think, ‘Oh my God, it was all a lie.’ I let her into my home and my kids’ lives.” Her feelings of betrayal were evident as she recounted ignoring red flags due to her trust in Finch.

Personal Reflections

While Jessica admitted she wasn’t entirely shocked by the news, Camilla experienced a more intense emotional response.

Camilla shared, “You watch these documentaries and think, ‘I would have known,’ but then you realize you truly did not know. It makes you question your instincts and yourself.”

Both actresses acknowledged the self-doubt that came from feeling misled, with Jessica noting it never occurred to her to doubt Finch.

Jessica stated, “It never occurred to me to not believe her. The things she lied about were things you could never imagine questioning.”

Moving Forward

As the episode continued, Camilla and Jessica discussed the broader implications of such deception on personal and professional relationships. They expressed hopes for healing and understanding for everyone involved, including Finch.

The scandal surrounding Elizabeth Finch serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities of trust and deception in human relationships. Through their candid reflections, Camilla and Jessica invite listeners to consider the significance of honesty in their own lives, while Anatomy of Lies sheds light on the troubling dynamics of deception in the world of entertainment.