In a heated discussion on ESPN’s First Take, Stephen A. Smith weighed in on the Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback situation, particularly focusing on the potential shift from Justin Fields to Russell Wilson. As the Steelers prepare for their upcoming game against the Jets, the decision looms large for head coach Mike Tomlin.

Stephen A. emphasized Wilson’s proven track record, stating, “We know Fields never had Super Bowl form, but Russ did.” This statement reflects the prevailing sentiment among some analysts that Wilson’s experience and previous success could be crucial for the Steelers as they navigate a tough part of their schedule.

The debate centers on whether Tomlin should stick with Fields, who has shown promise but lacks the playoff pedigree of a veteran like Wilson. Fields has had flashes of brilliance, keeping the Steelers competitive with a current 4-2 record. However, Smith argued that Wilson’s history as a two-time Super Bowl participant gives him an edge in high-pressure situations.

The discussion also touched on the dynamics within the Steelers’ locker room. Analysts speculate that veteran players may be more inclined to rally around Wilson, believing that he can elevate the team’s performance despite recent struggles. Critics point out that Wilson’s past few seasons have been rocky, particularly during his time in Denver. Still, Smith insists that the opportunity to leverage Wilson’s leadership and experience might outweigh the risks.

As the Steelers face a crucial matchup ahead, the question remains: Should Tomlin trust Fields’ potential or gamble on Wilson’s storied career? The stakes are high, and this decision could significantly impact the team’s playoff aspirations.

As First Take continues to explore this unfolding story, fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see who gets the nod as QB1 for the Steelers this Sunday.