As the 2024 NFL season heads into its final stretch, a compelling debate has emerged around Saquon Barkley’s pursuit of a historic rushing record. Barkley recently surpassed the 2,000-yard rushing mark, and with just 101 yards left to break Eric Dickerson’s single-season record of 2,105 yards, the question has become: should Barkley continue to chase the record, or is it time to rest him and prepare for the playoffs?
Both Shannon Sharpe and Dan Orlovsky have weighed in, and surprisingly, they both agree—Barkley should play to chase the record. Here’s why they think so.
The Case for Barkley to Chase the Record
Sharpe and Orlovsky both highlight the significance of reaching 2,000 rushing yards in the NFL. In a season where individual achievements can often be overshadowed by team goals, Barkley’s pursuit of history is a rare and monumental opportunity.
Sharpe draws parallels to past players who have chased individual records despite having already secured a playoff spot. He reminisces about Terrell Davis in 1998, when the Denver Broncos offensive line rallied to help him reach 2,000 yards. For Sharpe, this moment was about legacy—about making history that would be remembered forever. “This isn’t just about Saquon; it’s about the offensive line, the team, and the history of the franchise,” Sharpe asserts. “When you get this close to something historic, you have to go for it.”
Orlovsky also believes that playing for the record is about seizing a rare chance. He points out that Barkley’s success on the field has been driven not only by his talent but also by the commitment of his teammates. “This is not just about Barkley getting the record,” says Orlovsky. “This is a team moment. This offensive line has been incredible. They want to be part of this story.” Orlovsky believes the team, the coaches, and the fans all have a stake in seeing this record fall.
Barkley’s Mindset: Personal Goals vs. Team Goals
While the record is within reach, Barkley himself has been clear that his ultimate goal isn’t just personal success. In an interview, he stated, “I came here to do something special, and obviously breaking a record is special, but I want to be part of something bigger. I want a banner up there.” This reveals his focus on both individual and team goals. However, with the playoffs on the horizon, the decision to risk injury or rest up for a playoff run is a difficult one for Barkley and his coaching staff.
Sharpe encourages Barkley to be a little selfish this time. “This is a moment that might not come around again,” Sharpe says. “When you’re that close, you have to take the opportunity. Go after that record.” Orlovsky concurs, stating that this is a rare opportunity for Barkley to make his name in the NFL record books, and it might not come around again anytime soon.
The Team’s Responsibility: To Play or Rest?
While Barkley’s individual pursuit of the record is important, both Sharpe and Orlovsky emphasize the broader impact on the team’s success. Should the Giants rest their star running back, or should they push him to break the record? Orlovsky argues that if the Giants have already locked up their playoff spot, the best strategy might be to use the final regular-season game to go for the record while ensuring Barkley isn’t overexerted. “If I were Nick Sirianni,” he says, referring to the Eagles’ head coach, “I would give Saquon a half. Let him go out there and try to get those yards, but if he’s not close, then let him rest.”
Sharpe agrees, noting that the risk is small when you consider how close Barkley is. “We’re talking about 100 yards. That could come in just a few carries, and then you’re done. Why not go for it?” he argues.
The Giants’ Future: What’s at Stake?
For the Giants, the decision on whether to play Barkley for the record has bigger implications than just one player’s achievement. The team’s future could hinge on securing a higher draft pick, and with Barkley playing, they risk falling in the draft order. However, Sharpe and Orlovsky both agree that players are always playing for their pride and legacy. As Orlovsky points out, “You can’t take away the feeling of accomplishing something like this.”
Ultimately, the decision will depend on the priorities of the coaching staff. Do they value the opportunity for Barkley to make history, or do they focus on preparing for the postseason? Sharpe and Orlovsky believe the team should support Barkley’s pursuit. “This is an opportunity to do something special,” Sharpe says. “Don’t let it pass by.”
Conclusion
In the end, Sharpe and Orlovsky both firmly believe that Saquon Barkley should play to chase the record. While the Giants’ long-term success and playoff aspirations are important, achieving greatness in the present should not be overlooked. This moment is one that could cement Barkley’s legacy in NFL history, and both analysts agree that, with the right support, Barkley should go for it.
