Is CJ Donaldson Falling Short of Expectations? Here’s How WVU Can Support Their Star Running Back

The West Virginia Mountaineers had high hopes for their powerful running back CJ Donaldson heading into the 2024 season, especially with his promising pairing with Jahiem White in what was anticipated as a dynamic backfield. However, as the season has progressed, Donaldson’s performance has yet to meet the lofty expectations set by fans and coaches. His recent numbers have dipped, leaving questions about what’s holding him back and how the team can optimize his role.

Donaldson’s Stats: A Slow Season for a Promising Player

In nine games, Donaldson has rushed 104 times, amassing only 465 yards and six touchdowns, averaging 4.5 yards per carry. He’s crossed the 100-yard mark only once, against FCS opponent Albany. Since then, his performances have been modest, peaking at 79 yards against Pitt and 77 against Oklahoma State. Over the past four games, he has gained only 104 yards on 33 carries, averaging 3.2 yards per carry—a significant dip from his past performances. While last week’s low snap count against Cincinnati might have impacted his output, his overall trend remains concerning.

Possible Reasons for the Slump

The root cause of Donaldson’s struggles could be several factors, including lingering health issues or the coaching staff’s strategic decisions. Donaldson, who has been banged up over previous seasons, underwent surgery in the offseason. Although the staff felt confident about his health in fall camp, it’s possible he is still dealing with physical setbacks that limit his performance. Alternatively, the team may have lost some confidence in his ability to consistently deliver, leading to his decreased usage in certain game scenarios.

Questionable Usage Patterns

One of the biggest puzzles this season has been Donaldson’s role relative to White’s. While Donaldson has four more carries than White, the usage strategy has often appeared inconsistent with Donaldson’s strengths as a physical, between-the-tackles runner. Last season, Donaldson was the go-to back for hard-hitting runs up the middle, softening defenses for White to exploit with his speed and agility. This year, however, Donaldson seems to be playing second fiddle, and White, known for his agility, has been handling runs between the tackles more frequently.

Reverting to Donaldson as the primary “tone-setter” could benefit both backs. Allowing Donaldson to wear down opposing defenses first could amplify White’s effectiveness as a change-of-pace back, maximizing their complementary styles and forcing defenses to adapt mid-game. By returning Donaldson to his role as the punishing lead back, WVU may be able to open up the field for more explosive plays from both players.

Solutions to Get Donaldson Back on Track

To reignite Donaldson’s season, the Mountaineers can make some tactical changes to cater to his strengths and boost the offense as a whole:

Running the Right Plays for Donaldson

While mixing up play-calling is essential, running Donaldson too often on stretch or outside plays might be limiting his effectiveness. As a power back, Donaldson shines in short-yardage situations and between-the-tackles runs. On 3rd-and-short scenarios, for instance, there’s little need for finesse; Donaldson’s size and power are often enough to secure the necessary yardage. Avoiding excessive outside runs in favor of inside plays may help him build momentum and regain his rhythm.

Improving the Passing Game

A stronger passing attack would relieve pressure from the running game, allowing Donaldson and White to see less-crowded boxes. Quarterback Garrett Greene hasn’t been as effective with deep throws as he was last season, making it easier for defenses to stack up against the run. Freshman QB Nicco Marchiol has shown potential in throwing deep, but Coach Neal Brown has kept a conservative approach with him under center. Finding a way to balance the pass game, including more calculated deep throws, would prevent defenses from honing in on Donaldson and the rushing attack.

Consistency from the Offensive Line

While Donaldson’s dip in production is notable, his blockers share some responsibility. The left side of the offensive line, led by Wyatt Milum and Tomas Rimac, has been sharp, but the right side—where Brandon Yates, Ja’Quay Hubbard, and Nick Malone line up—has shown inconsistency with missed assignments. With tighter line play, Donaldson would benefit from clearer running lanes, and WVU’s ground game could regain its former momentum.

Looking Ahead: Will Donaldson Bounce Back?

As the season progresses, Donaldson’s production remains crucial, especially with matchups against Baylor and UCF ahead. These teams rank sixth and first, respectively, in the Big 12 for rushing, meaning Donaldson and White will be key in helping WVU control the tempo and keep pace. By fine-tuning his role and making the right adjustments, the Mountaineers can put Donaldson in the best position to make a stronger impact in the final stretch.

Donaldson has the potential and the skill set to regain his top form. By placing him in situations where he can capitalize on his power and skill as a between-the-tackles runner, the Mountaineers might just see the return of the standout rusher they hoped for this season.